I am a child......
From the heavens I come.....
To the world I am born......
Protect me from the virtual unreal word.....
Protect me from synthetic intrusion.......
Let me be in the world of reality.....
Let me learn intelligent things from the laws of nature.....
Let me be inspired by all thing lit with sunlight......
Let me live in harmony as does the merging of the seasons and the elements......
I am a child.....
Let me be one........
As a teacher of primary school children I see many forms of behaviour, some temporary and some consistent. I can see how easy it could be to take a list of symptoms that describe inattentiveness, impulsivity and hyperactivity and deem a child ADD or ADHD then proceed to have the child treated with stimulants.
I had a child come to my class from another school in Year 2 who had been on Ritalin for one year. Her mother claimed that she was inattentive at school and was behaving ‘badly’ at home. After some time of getting to know the child and her parents I became concerned for the girl; she was listless, appetiteless but well behaved and happy in a dull-like way. Her parents told me that there had been several adjustments to the medication and the dosage and not much changed her dull symptoms. I asked the parents to take her off the medication and with their doctor’s help they did. The improvement was instant, she shone, she was eating, she was loud, she was inattentive but she was alive. Family counselling helped the behavioural problems at home. At school, with the help of support teachers, I was able to find ways to make her lessons fulfilling enough that she didn’t get ‘bored’ and fidget and distract others. It wasn’t an easy ‘happy ever after’ story. But I ask…..is prescribing stimulants the right thing to do by our children?
My teenage daughter told me of a boy she knew who was diagnosed with ADHD and was on Ritalin so that he could concentrate at school. She also said that he was up until all hours of the night on the computer, playing computer games and watching TV all the time. Is he an example of an over stimulated child thus developing symptoms of ADHD and getting bored at school due to the lack of electronic easy-entertainment-where-he-doesn’t-have-to-apply-his-mind stimulation?
I have several children in my current class who would be classified as hyperactive and/or inattentive if I was to check off the list of symptoms. Fortunately being able to know the parents quite well I am able to ascertain where the root of some of the behaviours are. Some are just healthy over-energetic children who have a love for life, others do present hard-to-work-with behaviours and I know that they are exposed to an abundance of electronic stimulation. I can’t dictate what parents let their children do and not do but I can certainly not add to these children’s artificially imposed stimulation by supporting stimulant medication.
University of Queensland figures show that legal use of dexamphetamine in Australia has risen from 8.3 million tablets prescribed in 1984 to 38.4 million tablets in 2001. Over the same period Ritalin prescriptions rose from 1.5 million tablets to 19.3 million.” That’s scarry!
Myth #1: ADHD is a "phantom disorder".
The ‘Fact’ states that 95 years of scientific studies have consistently identified individuals who have trouble with concentration, impulse control and hyperactivity. It states that ADHD is a syndrome that is recognized by education departments, courts and institutes of health.
Myth #2: Ritalin is like cocaine, and the failure to give youngsters drug holidays from Ritalin causes them to develop psychosis.
The ‘Fact’ states that Ritalin is a medically prescribed stimulant medication that is chemically different from cocaine and that it does not cause addiction or dependence or lead to psychosis. An example is given that a child on drug holidays may be in more danger because his hyperactivity may cause him to run in front of traffic. Evidently fifty years of research has repeatedly shown that children, adolescents, and adults with ADHD safely benefit from treatment with methylphenidate.
Myth #3: No study has ever demonstrated that taking stimulant medications can cause any lasting behavioral or educational benefit to ADHD children.
The ‘Fact’ claims that research shows ADHD sufferers benefit from therapeutic treatment that has been safely used for over 50 years. An example was offered that The New York Times reviewed a recent study from Sweden showing positive long- term effects of stimulant medication therapy on children with ADHD.
Myth #4: ADHD kids are learning to make excuses, rather than take responsibility for their actions.
The ‘Fact’ states that experts teach children that ADHD is a challenge, not an excuse, and that medication corrects the chemical imbalance giving a fair chance of facing challenges.
Myth #5: ADHD is basically due to bad parenting and lack of discipline, and all that ADHD children really need is old-fashioned discipline, not any of these phony therapies.
The ‘Fact’ comments on the idea that there are parent-bashers who believe that misbehaviour is that the child is a ‘bad child’, but fortunately these days, more people are more enlightened. Dr. Russell Barkley and others have demonstrated that providing more discipline without any other interventions worsens rather than improves the behavior of children with ADHD.
Myth #6: Ritalin is unsafe, causing serious weight loss, mood swings, Tourette's syndrome, and sudden, unexplained deaths.
The ‘Fact’ emphasizes that there are no published cases of death from overdoses of Ritalin alone. The unexplained deaths are from a combination of Ritalin and other drugs and most of the deaths were contributed to unusual medical problems. It is claimed that many children do experience appetite loss and moodiness when Ritalin wears off, and that a small number may show temporary tics. It is also stated that Ritalin doesn’t permanently alter growth and usually doesn’t result in weight loss.
Myth #7: Teachers around the country routinely push pills on any students who are even a little inattentive or overactive.
The ’Fact’ points out that teachers’ responsibility is to bring to the parents’ attention the students behaviour so that the parents can seek help. The teacher’ position is not to diagnose ADHD, however, the symptoms must be present at home and at school.
Myth #8: Efforts by teachers to help children who have attentional problems can make more of a difference than medications such as Ritalin. The ‘Fact’ tells that evidence from trials suggest that this is a myth. The trials revealed that stimulant medication alone was compared to stimulant medication plus psychological educational treatment and found that the latter was not much better than the former. It is also stated that biological factors, if not altered by stimulants, will not show much change.
Myth #9: CH.A.D.D.(Children and adults with ADD) is supported by drug companies, and along with many professionals, are simply in this field to make a quick buck on ADHD.
The ‘Fact’ very defensively declares that CH.A.D.D. is very open about disclosing contributions from drug companies. The contributions support the national conference that consists of educational presentations on topics other than medication. CH.A.D.D. supports known effective treatments and takes positions against costly and unproven costly remedies.
Myth #10: It is not possible to accurately diagnose ADD or ADHD in children or adults.
The ‘Fact’ suggests that although scientists have not yet developed a single medical test for diagnosing ADHD, clinical diagnostic criteria have been developed, researched, and refined over several decades. The current generally accepted diagnostic criteria for ADHD are listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV).
Myth #11: Children outgrow ADD or ADHD.
The ‘Fact’ tells that ADHD is not only found in children and that studies show it often lasts a lifetime. Evidently over 70% of children will continue to manifest the full clinical syndrome in adolescence, and 15-50% will continue into adulthood. It is also claimed that if left untreated ADHD sufferers may develop secondary problems including depression, anxiety, substance abuse, academic failure, vocational problems, marital discord, and emotional distress. The ‘Fact’ states that if properly treated, most individuals with ADHD live productive lives and cope reasonably well with their symptoms.
Myth #12: Methylphenidate prescriptions in the U.S. have increased 600%.
The ‘Fact’ sheds a different light, saying that it is the production quotas have increased 600% and that methylphenidate is also prescribed for adults with ADHD, people with narcolepsy and geriatric patients. It is further stated that of the 3.5 million children who meet the criteria for ADHD, only about 50% are diagnosed and have stimulant medication.
Well, well, well….
Well, I have to say that after reading and re-reading the article I find it is over-toned and under-toned with the strong view that, yes, there is only one effective way to treat ADD and ADHD…..with stimulants.
There is no doubt that most recognize ADHD as something other than a phantom disorder. There is so much information about it. Based on my research, it is not really a ‘myth’ that Ritalin is like Cocaine. Such organizations as The People’s Voice and The Genetic Science Learning Centre at the University of Utah have similar views; Ritalin is very similar to Cocaine, they both have similar chemical structure and increase dopamine levels in the brain. They differ, in that Ritalin takes longer to reach the brain due to the fact it is an ingested pill rather than a sniffed powder.
In Myth 3, 'no study has demonstrated taking stimulant medications causes lasting benefit to ADHD children', the fact in the 'article' presents that there is evidence of lasting benefits. If I am to view brain-drugged settled behaviour as a beneficial result of ADHD stimulant medication treatment, then I assume their studies accurate.
So much emphasis of late has been put on the classification ADHD that unfortunately in some cases the relief of diagnosis makes an excuse for behaviour. I have seen for myself children that are happy to wear the label ‘ADHD’ on their forehead and take little responsibility for their actions. There is no harm in children knowing that certain behaviours are unacceptable.
So many things attribute to behaviors that qualify the diagnosis ADHD that there must be many ways to deal with the children displaying such symptoms. 'Focus on Adolescent Services’ homepage gives some good pointers before accepting a diagnosis of ADD or ADHD.
Some factors contributing to behavioral problems are excess television and computer games, food additives, allergies, exposure to chemicals, toxins and electro-magnetic fields. Adjusting parenting and disciplining techniques, or simply accepting the high-spirited child may help alleviate hard to handle behaviors enough to avoid stimulant medication.
If the criteria for diagnosis of ADD and ADHD is a list of symptoms that are measured as to severity and duration it cannot be possible to accurately diagnose. Factors such as those I have mentioned are variable, changeable and immeasurable.
News Target gives alarming information and evidence about the use of Ritalin, and now other anti-psychotic drugs are being prescribed to mask other symptoms. Ritalin does in many cases cause weight loss due to lack of appetite, I have observed this in children for myself. There are many studies that prove the weight loss factor. A ‘Drugs Information’ site reveals many warnings and side effects to be wary of when taking Ritalin.
It is concerning that the article ‘MYTHS ABOUT ADD & ADHD' plays down the effects of Ritalin, claiming “Myth 6: Ritalin is unsafe, causing serious weight loss, mood swings, Tourette's syndrome, and sudden, unexplained deaths.” It makes me suspicious of the defensive response about CH.A.D.D’s financial relationship to drug companies.
According to Travis Thompson, Ph.D. and Klaus Unna, M.D., the best-known effect of stimulant administration is psychosis. Evidence shows that Ritalin can cause shrinkage and other abnormalities in the brain. It would appear that the writers of the ‘article’ should research some more before they strongly claim methylphenidate does not lead to psychosis.
I have had children come to my class that have had teachers in other schools tell their parents that they need to have diagnosis for behavior and suggested that medication would be good for them. It is clear to me some teachers do prefer drugged children to make their life easier. I have heard a teacher say such a thing, and he meant it!
Myth 8 says “Efforts by teachers to help children who have attentional problems can make more of a difference than medications such as Ritalin”. This is no myth! Helping children through educational methods and classroom techniques is tried and true by many teachers, including me and other colleagues.
Thomas Armstrong. Ph.D. presents wholistic strategies by building on the child’s interests, learning styles and talents. He reminds us that many great figures whom transformed society were hyperactive type children.
We may not know of Winston Churchill, Pablo Picasso, Charles Darwin and Florence Nightingale if Ritalin had controlled their emotion, will and spirit.
We have so much information out there for us to wade through.
It is a moral question here…..
Is dulling a child’s emotions, controlling his behaviour with drugs the right thing to do?
From the heavens I come.....

To the world I am born......
Protect me from the virtual unreal word.....
Protect me from synthetic intrusion.......
Let me be in the world of reality.....
Let me learn intelligent things from the laws of nature.....
Let me be inspired by all thing lit with sunlight......
Let me live in harmony as does the merging of the seasons and the elements......
I am a child.....
Let me be one........
As a teacher of primary school children I see many forms of behaviour, some temporary and some consistent. I can see how easy it could be to take a list of symptoms that describe inattentiveness, impulsivity and hyperactivity and deem a child ADD or ADHD then proceed to have the child treated with stimulants.
I had a child come to my class from another school in Year 2 who had been on Ritalin for one year. Her mother claimed that she was inattentive at school and was behaving ‘badly’ at home. After some time of getting to know the child and her parents I became concerned for the girl; she was listless, appetiteless but well behaved and happy in a dull-like way. Her parents told me that there had been several adjustments to the medication and the dosage and not much changed her dull symptoms. I asked the parents to take her off the medication and with their doctor’s help they did. The improvement was instant, she shone, she was eating, she was loud, she was inattentive but she was alive. Family counselling helped the behavioural problems at home. At school, with the help of support teachers, I was able to find ways to make her lessons fulfilling enough that she didn’t get ‘bored’ and fidget and distract others. It wasn’t an easy ‘happy ever after’ story. But I ask…..is prescribing stimulants the right thing to do by our children?
My teenage daughter told me of a boy she knew who was diagnosed with ADHD and was on Ritalin so that he could concentrate at school. She also said that he was up until all hours of the night on the computer, playing computer games and watching TV all the time. Is he an example of an over stimulated child thus developing symptoms of ADHD and getting bored at school due to the lack of electronic easy-entertainment-where-he-doesn’t-have-to-apply-his-mind stimulation?
I have several children in my current class who would be classified as hyperactive and/or inattentive if I was to check off the list of symptoms. Fortunately being able to know the parents quite well I am able to ascertain where the root of some of the behaviours are. Some are just healthy over-energetic children who have a love for life, others do present hard-to-work-with behaviours and I know that they are exposed to an abundance of electronic stimulation. I can’t dictate what parents let their children do and not do but I can certainly not add to these children’s artificially imposed stimulation by supporting stimulant medication.
University of Queensland figures show that legal use of dexamphetamine in Australia has risen from 8.3 million tablets prescribed in 1984 to 38.4 million tablets in 2001. Over the same period Ritalin prescriptions rose from 1.5 million tablets to 19.3 million.” That’s scarry!
As a result of my conviction to keep children ‘artificial stimulant free’ I researched a number of sites.
I present an article titled:by
Becky Booth, Wilma Fellman, LPC, Judy Greenbaum, Ph.D., Terry Matlen, ACSW, Geraldine Markel, Ph.D., Howard Morris, Arthur L. Robin, Ph.D., Angela Tzelepis, Ph.D. was presented by ADDA (Attention Deficit Disorder Association).
The article defined twelve myths in relation to ADD and ADHD and presented factual responses to each of them. The following is an ouline:Myth #1: ADHD is a "phantom disorder".
The ‘Fact’ states that 95 years of scientific studies have consistently identified individuals who have trouble with concentration, impulse control and hyperactivity. It states that ADHD is a syndrome that is recognized by education departments, courts and institutes of health.
Myth #2: Ritalin is like cocaine, and the failure to give youngsters drug holidays from Ritalin causes them to develop psychosis.
The ‘Fact’ states that Ritalin is a medically prescribed stimulant medication that is chemically different from cocaine and that it does not cause addiction or dependence or lead to psychosis. An example is given that a child on drug holidays may be in more danger because his hyperactivity may cause him to run in front of traffic. Evidently fifty years of research has repeatedly shown that children, adolescents, and adults with ADHD safely benefit from treatment with methylphenidate.
Myth #3: No study has ever demonstrated that taking stimulant medications can cause any lasting behavioral or educational benefit to ADHD children.
The ‘Fact’ claims that research shows ADHD sufferers benefit from therapeutic treatment that has been safely used for over 50 years. An example was offered that The New York Times reviewed a recent study from Sweden showing positive long- term effects of stimulant medication therapy on children with ADHD.
Myth #4: ADHD kids are learning to make excuses, rather than take responsibility for their actions.
The ‘Fact’ states that experts teach children that ADHD is a challenge, not an excuse, and that medication corrects the chemical imbalance giving a fair chance of facing challenges.
Myth #5: ADHD is basically due to bad parenting and lack of discipline, and all that ADHD children really need is old-fashioned discipline, not any of these phony therapies.
The ‘Fact’ comments on the idea that there are parent-bashers who believe that misbehaviour is that the child is a ‘bad child’, but fortunately these days, more people are more enlightened. Dr. Russell Barkley and others have demonstrated that providing more discipline without any other interventions worsens rather than improves the behavior of children with ADHD.
Myth #6: Ritalin is unsafe, causing serious weight loss, mood swings, Tourette's syndrome, and sudden, unexplained deaths.
The ‘Fact’ emphasizes that there are no published cases of death from overdoses of Ritalin alone. The unexplained deaths are from a combination of Ritalin and other drugs and most of the deaths were contributed to unusual medical problems. It is claimed that many children do experience appetite loss and moodiness when Ritalin wears off, and that a small number may show temporary tics. It is also stated that Ritalin doesn’t permanently alter growth and usually doesn’t result in weight loss.
Myth #7: Teachers around the country routinely push pills on any students who are even a little inattentive or overactive.
The ’Fact’ points out that teachers’ responsibility is to bring to the parents’ attention the students behaviour so that the parents can seek help. The teacher’ position is not to diagnose ADHD, however, the symptoms must be present at home and at school.
Myth #8: Efforts by teachers to help children who have attentional problems can make more of a difference than medications such as Ritalin. The ‘Fact’ tells that evidence from trials suggest that this is a myth. The trials revealed that stimulant medication alone was compared to stimulant medication plus psychological educational treatment and found that the latter was not much better than the former. It is also stated that biological factors, if not altered by stimulants, will not show much change.
Myth #9: CH.A.D.D.(Children and adults with ADD) is supported by drug companies, and along with many professionals, are simply in this field to make a quick buck on ADHD.
The ‘Fact’ very defensively declares that CH.A.D.D. is very open about disclosing contributions from drug companies. The contributions support the national conference that consists of educational presentations on topics other than medication. CH.A.D.D. supports known effective treatments and takes positions against costly and unproven costly remedies.
Myth #10: It is not possible to accurately diagnose ADD or ADHD in children or adults.
The ‘Fact’ suggests that although scientists have not yet developed a single medical test for diagnosing ADHD, clinical diagnostic criteria have been developed, researched, and refined over several decades. The current generally accepted diagnostic criteria for ADHD are listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV).
Myth #11: Children outgrow ADD or ADHD.
The ‘Fact’ tells that ADHD is not only found in children and that studies show it often lasts a lifetime. Evidently over 70% of children will continue to manifest the full clinical syndrome in adolescence, and 15-50% will continue into adulthood. It is also claimed that if left untreated ADHD sufferers may develop secondary problems including depression, anxiety, substance abuse, academic failure, vocational problems, marital discord, and emotional distress. The ‘Fact’ states that if properly treated, most individuals with ADHD live productive lives and cope reasonably well with their symptoms.
Myth #12: Methylphenidate prescriptions in the U.S. have increased 600%.
The ‘Fact’ sheds a different light, saying that it is the production quotas have increased 600% and that methylphenidate is also prescribed for adults with ADHD, people with narcolepsy and geriatric patients. It is further stated that of the 3.5 million children who meet the criteria for ADHD, only about 50% are diagnosed and have stimulant medication.
Well, well, well….
Well, I have to say that after reading and re-reading the article I find it is over-toned and under-toned with the strong view that, yes, there is only one effective way to treat ADD and ADHD…..with stimulants.
There is no doubt that most recognize ADHD as something other than a phantom disorder. There is so much information about it. Based on my research, it is not really a ‘myth’ that Ritalin is like Cocaine. Such organizations as The People’s Voice and The Genetic Science Learning Centre at the University of Utah have similar views; Ritalin is very similar to Cocaine, they both have similar chemical structure and increase dopamine levels in the brain. They differ, in that Ritalin takes longer to reach the brain due to the fact it is an ingested pill rather than a sniffed powder.
In Myth 3, 'no study has demonstrated taking stimulant medications causes lasting benefit to ADHD children', the fact in the 'article' presents that there is evidence of lasting benefits. If I am to view brain-drugged settled behaviour as a beneficial result of ADHD stimulant medication treatment, then I assume their studies accurate.
So much emphasis of late has been put on the classification ADHD that unfortunately in some cases the relief of diagnosis makes an excuse for behaviour. I have seen for myself children that are happy to wear the label ‘ADHD’ on their forehead and take little responsibility for their actions. There is no harm in children knowing that certain behaviours are unacceptable.
So many things attribute to behaviors that qualify the diagnosis ADHD that there must be many ways to deal with the children displaying such symptoms. 'Focus on Adolescent Services’ homepage gives some good pointers before accepting a diagnosis of ADD or ADHD.
Some factors contributing to behavioral problems are excess television and computer games, food additives, allergies, exposure to chemicals, toxins and electro-magnetic fields. Adjusting parenting and disciplining techniques, or simply accepting the high-spirited child may help alleviate hard to handle behaviors enough to avoid stimulant medication.
If the criteria for diagnosis of ADD and ADHD is a list of symptoms that are measured as to severity and duration it cannot be possible to accurately diagnose. Factors such as those I have mentioned are variable, changeable and immeasurable.
News Target gives alarming information and evidence about the use of Ritalin, and now other anti-psychotic drugs are being prescribed to mask other symptoms. Ritalin does in many cases cause weight loss due to lack of appetite, I have observed this in children for myself. There are many studies that prove the weight loss factor. A ‘Drugs Information’ site reveals many warnings and side effects to be wary of when taking Ritalin.
It is concerning that the article ‘MYTHS ABOUT ADD & ADHD' plays down the effects of Ritalin, claiming “Myth 6: Ritalin is unsafe, causing serious weight loss, mood swings, Tourette's syndrome, and sudden, unexplained deaths.” It makes me suspicious of the defensive response about CH.A.D.D’s financial relationship to drug companies.
According to Travis Thompson, Ph.D. and Klaus Unna, M.D., the best-known effect of stimulant administration is psychosis. Evidence shows that Ritalin can cause shrinkage and other abnormalities in the brain. It would appear that the writers of the ‘article’ should research some more before they strongly claim methylphenidate does not lead to psychosis.
I have had children come to my class that have had teachers in other schools tell their parents that they need to have diagnosis for behavior and suggested that medication would be good for them. It is clear to me some teachers do prefer drugged children to make their life easier. I have heard a teacher say such a thing, and he meant it!
Myth 8 says “Efforts by teachers to help children who have attentional problems can make more of a difference than medications such as Ritalin”. This is no myth! Helping children through educational methods and classroom techniques is tried and true by many teachers, including me and other colleagues.
Thomas Armstrong. Ph.D. presents wholistic strategies by building on the child’s interests, learning styles and talents. He reminds us that many great figures whom transformed society were hyperactive type children.
We may not know of Winston Churchill, Pablo Picasso, Charles Darwin and Florence Nightingale if Ritalin had controlled their emotion, will and spirit.
We have so much information out there for us to wade through.
It is a moral question here…..
Is dulling a child’s emotions, controlling his behaviour with drugs the right thing to do?







